US announces end of Iranian blockade by September 30, 2026? REJECTED

Side
YES
My estimate
0.25-0.35 (core ~0.30)
Proposed price
20.5%
Market price
Date
2026-09-11

Reasoning

REJECTED 2/2 (Kimi k3 returned empty output 3x; per rules proceeded with 2 models, both required to approve - neither did). Astra REJECT conf 8: excerpts support pressure but not >20.5% probability of official unambiguous general suspension in 19 days; 18% face-saving-path allocation speculative, pathways may overlap; CSMonitor midterms expectation does not support a SEPTEMBER announcement; Alhurra anonymous statement does not establish end-of-blockade signal; Jordan exhaustion unconfirmed. Fable REJECT conf 7: evidence mostly undercuts thesis - Trump explicitly waiting until AFTER midterms; deadline precedes midterms; interceptor depletion constrains air defense, not naval blockade enforcement (no causal link); edge within own stated range's noise; sources 2-4 don't support YES as framed.

Lesson

Face-saving-announcement paths are speculative without any reporting hint; permissive criteria language establishes what COULD qualify, not likelihood. Deadline placement matters: market deadline Sep 30 sits BEFORE the midterms the administration is visibly waiting for - the same facts that argue for eventual blockade end argue for NO resolution by Sep 30. Also: Sweden PM market (Andersson 0.725, election Sep 13) checked and skipped - polls near dead heat (Ipsos 49.0 vs 49.3 bloc gap), price roughly fair, no edge.

Evidence sources

FactSource
outcomes [Yes,No], prices [0.205,0.795]; resolution = official, unambiguous US govt announcement of general end/suspension of naval blockade before Sep 30 11:59 PM ET; partial exemptions don't countgamma-api.polymarket.com/markets?id=3128887…
Sep 11: June agreement crumbled, no diplomatic progress; Iranian exports 1.85M->~255k bpd; war $37.5B, unpopular, expected to weigh on Republicans in Nov midterms; interceptors strainedwww.pbs.org/newshour/world/the-u-s-has-made-progress-in…
Sep 11: CENTCOM redirected 96 vessels as of Sep 10; Iran hit US drone - blockade active/escalatingnews.cgtn.com/news/2026-09-11/Iran-hits-US-drone-in-Hor…
Sep 10: Trump appears to have given up on nuclear deal; expects war through midterms, cease 'immediately' after; officials reportedly consider post-midterm ramp-upwww.csmonitor.com/World/Middle-East/2026/0910/iran-nucl…
Jul 30: <850 Patriot, ~250 THAAD interceptors left (CSIS); $58.6B replenishment dealwww.armytimes.com/industry/techwatch/2026/07/30/us-stri…

Council verdicts

ModelVerdictConfCostGeneration
openai/gpt-6-astraREJECT8 gen-1789152622-GSjHvGaMb
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1REJECT7 gen-1789152632-52K4K7wcD
moonshotai/kimi-k3no output (3 attempts, generat